Hey, I've only just seen this post -- I'm responding to what you say about: "Lucy's characterization of Susan in The Last Battle"
Protest! protest! Lucy doesn't say a single word about Susan in The Last Battle! It's absolutely unmissable that the three who criticise her are the three who know her least. Peter makes a single factual (from his POV, anyway) statement and declines to talk about her otherwise. Lucy, Edmund and Professor Kirke say nothing at all about her.
no subject
"Lucy's characterization of Susan in The Last Battle"
Protest! protest! Lucy doesn't say a single word about Susan in The Last Battle! It's absolutely unmissable that the three who criticise her are the three who know her least. Peter makes a single factual (from his POV, anyway) statement and declines to talk about her otherwise. Lucy, Edmund and Professor Kirke say nothing at all about her.